A Thief’s Prayer
Scripture: Luke 23:39–43 (CEB)
Part of the Witness at the Cross Lenten series

In this week’s sermon, we remain at the cross and listen closely to a voice we might otherwise overlook—a condemned criminal hanging beside Jesus. In Luke’s Gospel, two men are crucified with him. One joins the chorus of mockery: “Aren’t you the Christ? Save yourself and us.” The other does something astonishing.

He sees a king.

While religious leaders sneer, soldiers gamble, and a sign above Jesus’ head reads “King of the Jews,” this dying man recognizes what others cannot. He tells the truth about himself—“We are rightly condemned.” He declares Jesus’ innocence—“This man has done nothing wrong.” And then he dares to believe that Jesus’ kingdom is still coming.

“Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom.”

Not if. When.

Drawing on insights from Amy-Jill Levine’s Witness at the Cross, we reflect on how this second criminal represents a radically different response to Jesus’ suffering. With nothing left to prove, no reputation to defend, and no time to make amends, he offers only an honest heart and a simple prayer. And in response, Jesus speaks one of the most grace-filled promises in all of Scripture:

“Today you will be with me in paradise.”

Throughout Christian history, believers have tried to explain how the cross accomplishes salvation—through ransom, satisfaction, substitution, moral influence, Christus Victor, and more. Yet what they all share is this: our salvation rests on God’s action, not our own. Jesus does what we cannot do.

The thief understands this before any theologian names it. He brings no good works, no theological credentials, no time to “get it right.” His only claim is this: “The man on the middle cross said I could come.” And that is enough.

As we prepare to come to the table of grace and reflect at the prayer stations, we are invited to release our regrets, fears, and shame into the hands of the crucified King. The kingdom that comes through the cross is not built on force or self-protection. It is a kingdom where grace meets us at our worst moment, where a King dies even for his enemies, and where Jesus looks at us and says, “I remember you. You’re with me.”

🌀 Reflection Questions:

• Does seeing Jesus as a suffering King change the way you imagine God’s power?
• The thief’s only credential for paradise was, “The man on the middle cross said I could come.” How does this simple truth challenge or comfort you in your faith journey?
• How does focusing on our salvation originating in God’s action through Christ—rather than our faith or our works—influence your daily walk with Jesus?

✨ Listen as we stand between two crosses, hear a dying man’s prayer, and rediscover the grace that welcomes us—not because we have earned it, but because Christ has spoken.

Support the show